The
first settlement in the Brookville area dates from 1796, when
Joseph and Andrew Barnett and Samuel Scott arrived at the confluence
of
Sandy Lick and Mill Creeks, in the area east of town known as
Port Barnett. For the next thirty years, settlement was slow,
due primarily
to the rugged and heavily-timbered terrain. In 1830 the town
of Brookville was established and designated the County Seat. The
original plan of the town was bounded on the north by Butler
Street and on the west by an alley just east of the present Presbyterian
Church. To the south and east, lots were laid out east of Pickering
Street, near the Memorial Park, and on the east side of town
between
North Fork Creek and Taylor Street.
Brookville's early growth can be attributed to its location along the Susquehanna and Waterford Pike, a toll road completed in 1822 between the Susquehanna River in Clearfield County and Waterford, in Erie County. By 1832, just two years after the town was planned, there were forty dwellings, a brick Courthouse, four stores, and four taverns.